Skip to content

Forecast Update: Impact of Covid-19 on the Arkansas Economic Outlook (April)

In a report released on March 23, AEDI presented a preliminary forecast for the Arkansas economy, taking into account the impact of the novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).  In addition to disruption of world supply chains, the decline in consumer spending associated with “social distancing” is generating forecasts with significant declines in aggregate demand, creating the conditions for a severe recession.

In this note we update that forecast with new estimates of the magnitude of the downturn, taking into account the impact of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act into law on March 27.  We also update and extend our previous guidance on how the forecast is likely to impact sales tax receipts of local governments.

The forecast is based on the latest update to the national outlook from IHS Markit, dated April 2, 2020.  The new forecast sees GDP growth falling at a 26.5% annual rate in the second quarter – down from a 12.6% rate of decline forecast just two weeks earlier.  National unemployment is now projected to peak at over 10% in the fourth quarter of the year.  According to IHS, the new forecast “reflects inclusion of new high-frequency data and reports on developments in industries directly affected by social distancing, as well as new judgment on how efforts to slow the spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) will permeate the economy.”

As with our previous forecast for the Arkansas economy, we have applied the recent IHS forecast adjustments to our model for Arkansas, adjusting the components of each aggregate separately in order to capture the unique characteristics of the Arkansas economy. Our state forecast is also informed by an update to the IHS Arkansas model published on March 27 that reflected the March 20 national forecast assumptions.

In a nutshell, the latest forecast projects far sharper downturns in employment and consumer spending, with deeper and broader effects.  Nonfarm payrolls are expected to decline by over 100,000 and unemployment is expected to peak at 9.2%.  Consumer spending is expected to be down over 9% in the second quarter.  Most components of income are also expected to decline more sharply than in the previous forecast, but estimates of transfer payments stemming from the CARES Act are expected to buffer the impact on total personal income.

The following sections present our latest post-COVID-19 forecasts for Arkansas, comparing the projections to our forecast from March 30, as well as the previous, pre-COVID-19 baseline forecast. 

Employment
The latest forecast indicates a decline of 108,000 jobs by the fourth quarter of 2020, an 8.4% drop.  The previous forecast had indicated a loss of 77,000 jobs.

Figure 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

As shown in Table 1, job losses are concentrated in service-providing sectors that are considered especially impacted by “social distancing.”  However, the new forecast shows declines across the entire economy. Even Health Care & Social Assistance is now expected to see job losses by the end of the year.  In light of new patterns of consumer behavior, some sectors have been revised to show smaller declines than previously forecasted.  For example, employment in Accommodation and Food Services was previously expected to decline by 13%, but drive-through, carry-out, and delivery options are now anticipated to limit that sector’s decline to only 9%.  Employment in nondurable goods production—primarily in food processing—is expected to decline by only 2.9%, as opposed to a previously-forecast decline of 3.5%.  The largest downward revisions are associated with employment in sectors that are not directly impacted by COVID-19 or social-distancing practices, as the effects of the economic downturn spread throughout the economy.

Table 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Unemployment
The Arkansas unemployment rate was previously forecast to peak at 8.7%.  The latest forecast suggests 9.2%. As dire as that sounds, the forecast for Arkansas is lower than the national projection of 10.3%.  The increase in forecasted unemployment is buffered somewhat, particularly in this most recent forecast, by a decline in the labor force participation rate.  The participation rate is expected to fall by over a full percentage point, from 56.8% to 55.5%.

Figure 2:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Personal Income
The latest forecast for personal income includes a surge in transfer payments in the second quarter of 2020, reflecting payments associated with automatic stabilizers such as unemployment insurance, as well as the large cash transfers approved under the CARES Act.  In the U.S. forecasts, IHS Markit predicts an increase of nearly 24% in second-quarter transfers, with an additional 3% increase in the third quarter.  That translates to a path for total personal income that is basically flat through the third quarter (down 0.2% from Q1).

If we apply the national adjustment factors directly to personal income, Arkansas follows a similar trajectory—labeled as “U.S. Equivalent” in Figure 3.  However, transfer payments account for a larger share of total personal income in Arkansas than for the U.S. average (about 24% vs. 17%).  Consequently, if transfer payments surge by as much as 24% in the second quarter, Arkansas would see an increase in total income through the third quarter – up 2.6% from Q1 (labeled as “April Forecast” in Figure 3). 

Figure 3:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Is it reasonable to expect transfer payments to increase in the same proportions as the national total?  On the one hand, a given dollar-amount transfer payment translates to a smaller percentage increase when the base is larger, so we might expect something smaller than a 24% increase in Arkansas.  On the other hand, as a relatively low-income state we are likely to have fewer people excluded from transfer programs by means-testing.  Looking back to the stimulus programs of the “great recession,” transfer payments in the second quarter of 2008 were up from the previous year by 25.6% (U.S.) and 25.3% (Arkansas).  So it is, perhaps, not unreasonable to expect similar growth rates of transfer payments in the present situation.  All of this discussion highlights the fact that there is considerable uncertainty about all forecasts, particularly in unusual times and circumstances.

Overall, the new personal income forecasts indicate sharper declines in all categories of earnings and other income, but higher transfer payments will significantly offset those losses, at least for a time.

Consumer Spending
Despite the boost to incomes from expected transfer payments, the balance of forces is now expected to result in sharper declines in Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) than in the previous forecast.  Spending in the second quarter is now projected to decline by 9%, with additional weakness expected in the first quarter statistics as well (-0.7%).  The trajectory for recovery is now more optimistic, however, with growth beginning to rebound in the third quarter.

Figure 4:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Table 2 shows the initial declines expected for components of consumer spending, comparing the previous forecast to the current outlook.  As is typically the case during recessions, durable goods purchases are expected to fall dramatically, with declines in purchase of motor vehicles down 33%.  Nondurable Goods purchases are less-affected during economic declines, and particularly in the present situation with meals-at-home substituting for dining-out, overall Nondurable Goods purchases are expected to decline by less than 7%.  Nondurables also includes gasoline, where price reductions account for much of a 42% drop in spending, as well as Food and Beverages Purchased for Off-premises Consumption, which are expected to increase by 15%.  Spending on services also tends to be more resilient to economic downturns, but some sectors in particular are expected to show sharp declines.  While overall spending on services is projected to decline less than 9%, spending on Recreation is expected to drop by 40% and Accommodations and Food Services by over 60%.

Table 2:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Figure 5 shows index values (relative to 2019:Q4=100), illustrating the relative paths for total PCE, Durable Goods, Nondurable Goods (less Gasoline & Other Energy) and Services.  The relative severity of the downturn in Durable Goods is evident.  With the exclusion of gasoline, Nondurable Goods are projected to show a modest decline in the second quarter and remain relatively stable.  However, the dashed line shows that the stability of Nondurables is attributable to Food and Beverages Purchased for Off-Premises Consumption.

Figure 5:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Implications for Local Sales Tax Collections
In a follow-up to our forecast from two weeks ago, we prepared a report on how changes in consumer spending are likely to affect local sales tax collections.  This section presents an update on that report.

For assessing the impact on county and municipal sales tax collections, the question is how the tax base is reflected in the various components of spending.  Durable goods are taxable and represent a significant share of the sales tax base.  Nondurable goods, excluding gasoline, are also taxable.  Services are generally not taxable, with the exception of some categories that are expected to be hard-hit by the downturn; in particular, Recreation and Food Services & Accommodation.  On the other hand, the surge in grocery sales represent a component of county and municipal sales tax bases that should help offset declines in other categories.

As a proxy for local sales tax bases in Arkansas, we take a simple sum of Durable Goods plus Nondurable Goods (less Gasoline and other energy) plus two services components, Recreation and Food Services & Accommodation.  This isn’t a perfect measure.  For example, it excludes the utilities component of Housing and Utilities, as well as some taxable components of Other Services.  Moreover, as a measure of consumer spending, it does not include some taxable business-to-business sales.  Nevertheless, this aggregate measures some of the key components of the tax base. 

Figure 6 shows the trajectory of this measure compared to total Personal Consumption Expenditures.  Figure 6 also compares the current outlook to our previous forecast, in which grocery sales were expected to buffer the decline in other categories of spending.  In the new forecast, the steepness of declines in spending on Durable Goods, Recreation, and Food Services & Accommodation overwhelms the grocery effect.  The proxy for taxable sales was projected to decline by 4% from 2019:Q4 through 2020:Q2 in the March forecast.  Now it is expected to fall by 18% and it is not expected to recover to 2019 levels until late in 2021.

Figure 6:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Figure 7 breaks down the outlook for the taxable sales proxy in two ways:  as year-over-year growth rates and as deviations from trend.  It is hoped that these figures might help local governments anticipate the timing and magnitude of declines in taxable sales and tax revenue.

In terms of year-over-year growth rates, the first quarter of 2020 is now expected to have declined by nearly 3% from the previous year.  The second quarter year-over-year growth rate drops to -16.8%.   The figures for deviations from trend illustrate the lasting impact of reduced revenues relative to a pre-existing outlook, dropping to 18% below-trend and remaining in negative territory through the end of 2021.

Figure 7:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

These estimates suggest large declines in sales beginning in the second quarter.  There is typically a one-month lag in the remittance of sales tax proceeds by the vendors and an additional month before the revenue shows up in local government accounts.  Hence, the hit to sales tax receipts might not show up in full impact until near the middle of calendar year 2020.

These comparisons are subject to a great deal of uncertainty.  They do not reflect seasonal patterns in the data and do not reflect regional differences in consumption patterns and growth trends.  As with any forecast, they should be used only as rough estimates. 

A PDF File of this report is available HERE.

Arkansas GDP – 2019:Q4

The U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis released a report this morning on state-level GDP for the fourth quarter of 2019. Arkansas real GDP increased at a 2.4% annual rate, surpassing the national average of 2.1%. Arkansas’ growth rate was the 13th highest in the nation.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

From four quarters earlier, Arkansas GDP increased 2.2%, nearly keeping pace with the national average of 2.3%.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

2019 Annual Data
Comparing 2019 to 2018, Arkansas GDP was up 1.8%, accelerating slightly from the 1.7% pace of the previous year. Growth in 2019 was the fastest since the 2.8% pace recorded in 2013.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Contributions to GDP growth in 2019 came mostly from service sectors, particularly those associated with information, finance, and professional & business services. Health care services were also a contributor to growth. Agriculture and nondurable goods manufacturing subtracted from annual growth.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Initial Claims for Unemployment Insurance – Week ending March 28

The latest report on initial claims for unemployment insurance, covering the week ending March 28, came out this morning. Nationwide, initial claims were up 6,648,000, more than double the size of the record-breaking increase from the previous week (which was revised up by 24,000). For Arkansas, initial claims totaled 26,944, nearly three times the number from the previous week. The Arkansas increase was a record high, exceeding even seasonal end-of-year peaks recorded in 2001 and 2002.

Source: Department of Labor

The report from the Department of Labor noted that comments from states continued to cite the COVID-19 virus as a factor, and that the job losses were “related to the services industries broadly, again led by accommodation and food services.” The report when on to report broader impacts: “Many states continued to cite the health care and social assistance, and manufacturing industries, while an increasing number of states identified the retail and wholesale trade and construction industries.”

In order to put the numbers in perspective: If we take the number of initial claims over the most recent two weeks, add that to the number of unemployed in February, and subtract it from the number of employed, we get a hypothetical unemployment rate for the U.S. of 9.2%. For Arkansas, the same calculation yields a hypothetical unemployment rate of 6.2%.

This is not how the actual unemployment rates are calculated. A survey polls individuals on their employment status during one “reference week” each month (usually the week including the 12th of the month). Consequently, the unemployment numbers for March are unlikely to capture the late-month surge in the newly unemployed.

Impact of Covid-19 on Arkansas Consumer Spending: Implications for Local Government Sales Tax Collections

(Revised and corrected, April 2, 2020)

In a report released on March 23, AEDI presented a preliminary forecast for the Arkansas economy, taking into account the impact of the novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).  In addition to disruption of world supply chains, the decline in consumer spending associated with “social distancing” is generating forecasts with significant declines in aggregate demand that make a recession appear inevitable.

In this note, we focus on consumer spending and the outlook for sales tax collections by county and municipal governments.

Social distancing practices are expected to have significant direct effect on consumer spending in the first and second quarters of 2020, with lingering effects due to the impact of declining employment and income later in the year and beyond. Total consumer spending is expected to decline by 5.1% in the second quarter of 2020. While some recovery is expected in the second half of 2020, total consumer spending is expected to remain well below the baseline forecast through the end of 2021. 

Figure 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

While the 5% decline in total PCE provides an indication of the overall impact of COVID-19 on overall consumer spending, sub-components show some widely differing trajectories.  Durable goods are expected to suffer the largest decline, dropping 10.4% from 2019:Q4 through 2020:Q2 and remaining below recent levels through the end of 2021.  Services show a smaller decline, 4.7%, and recover to positive territory by the end of 2020.  Nondurable goods (less Gasoline) are expected to increase through the second quarter of the year (+4.2%), driven by an increase in spending on Food & Beverages Purchased for Off-Premises Consumption.

Figure 2:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Table 1 shows the initial declines expected for components of consumer spending, along with cumulative changes expected by the first quarter of 2021. ( Table 1 is a corrected and extended version of a table presented in our previous forecast analysis.)

Table 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

For assessing the impact on county and municipal sales tax collections, the question is how the tax base is reflected in the various components of spending.  Durable goods are taxable and represent a significant share of the sales tax base.  Nondurable goods, excluding gasoline, are also taxable.  Services are generally not taxable, with the exception of some categories that are expected to be hard-hit by the downturn; in particular, Recreation and Food Services & Accommodation.  On the other hand, the surge in grocery sales represent a component of county and municipal sales tax bases, and should help buffer declines in other categories.

As a proxy for local sales tax bases in Arkansas, we take a simple sum of Durable Goods plus Nondurable Goods (less Gasoline and other energy) plus two services components, Recreation and Food Services & Accommodation.  This isn’t a perfect measure.  For example, it excludes the utilities component of Housing and Utilities, as well as some taxable components of Other Services.  Moreover, as a measure of consumer spending, it does not include some taxable business-to-business sales.  Nevertheless, this aggregate measures some of the key components of the tax base. 

Figure 3 shows the trajectory of this measure compared to total Personal Consumption Expenditures. Grocery sales boost this measure into positive territory for 2020:Q1, but by the second quarter the proxy declines by 4% relative to the end of 2019.  Recovery proceeds more slowly than for PCE, with the proxy not reaching recent levels until the third quarter of 2021.

Figure 3:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

In terms of year-over-year growth rates, the first quarter increase in grocery sales (along with growth through 2019) suggest a 6.2% increase for 2020:Q1.  The second quarter sees a decline of 0.6% compared to a year earlier, with the cumulative effects showing up as a 3.9% drop in the third quarter.  Further year-over-year declines are registered through the first quarter of 2021.

Figure 4:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

These comparisons are subject to a great deal of uncertainty.  They do not reflect regional differences in consumption patterns and growth trends.  They should be used only as rough estimates.   

Moreover, as we concluded in our earlier report, there is a great deal of uncertainty associated with any forecast of the current, unprecedented situation. Risks to the forecast are more likely to be on the down-side: The presumed scenario where economic recovery begins by the end of 2020 might prove to be overly optimistic. The declines in consumer spending and income may reinforce one another to create an even more dramatic downturn.  In fact, more recent national forecasts are suggesting far more dramatic declines in economic activity.

There are, however, two additional effects that might make the outlook appear less dire.  First, since 2019:Q3 the state has been collecting sales taxes from out-of-state internet vendors.  This should continue to boost year-over-year sales tax growth in the first half of 2020 (although the magnitude of this change is uncertain).  Second, the federal government has recently approved stimulus spending that will result in substantial inflows of purchasing power to our state.  We estimate that the personal tax rebates of $1,200 per person and $500 per child will result in almost $2 billion in additional purchasing power, representing about 1.9% of annual personal consumption expenditures.  If consumers spend this and other stimulus cash on taxable goods and services, the negative impact on taxable sales could be ameliorated considerably.

Note: A previous version of this report erroneously included an ad hoc adjustment for internet sales tax receipts. The growth rates reported here are more conservative, making no assumptions about how internet sales tax receipts might affect year-over-year growth comparisons in the first half of 2020.

A PDF file of this report is available HERE

Arkansas Employment and Unemployment – February 2020

The Bureau of Labor Statistics has released state-level data on employment and unemployment for the month of February. Arkansas’ unemployment rate remained unchanged for the month at 3.5%, matching the U.S. rate. The number of unemployed was down by 269 and the number of employed was up 1,239. As a result, the labor force expanded by 970.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

Initial Claims
We don’t normally track weekly initial claims for unemployment insurance, but yesterday’s release for the week ending March 21 was noteworthy. For the U.S., the number of new unemployment claims was 3,283,000, shattering the previous record-high of 695,000 recorded in October 1982. The labor department reported that “nearly every state providing comments cited the COVID-19 virus impacts” to explain the surge. In Arkansas, new claims were up by 8,958, an increase of 548% from the previous week. Most states experienced even larger increases, with the largest percentage gain being 3308% in New Hampshire. The increase in Arkansas was the 40th-largest percentage gain among the 50 states and District of Columbia.

The initial claims data give an indication of what is in store for upcoming unemployment reports. A simple back-of-the-envelope calculation — adding the number of new claims to the number of unemployed in February (and subtracting the same number from the number employed) — suggests a two percentage point increase in the national unemployment rate, from 3.5% to 5.5%. The same calculation for Arkansas suggests a smaller increase, from 3.5% to 4.2%. This is not the way the actual unemployment rate is calculated, but it is indicative of the magnitude and likely impact of the initial claims data that came out this week.

Payroll Employment
Arkansas nonfarm payroll employment declined by 2,900 in February. The number for January — originally reported as an increase of 400 — was revised to show a 400-job decline. February’s job total was slightly lower than the number posted for a year earlier (-700).

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

Employment in most sectors showed small changes, with the exceptions including job losses in Transportation & Utilities (-1,500) and Leisure & Hospitality Services (-2,200). Employment in the Professional & Business Services sector was up by 1,100.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

The year-over-year decline in employment includes prominent job-losses in Manufacturing (-3,000), Leisure & Hospitality Services (-2,300) and Retail Trade (-1,600). Employment in Government declined by 1,500 compared to year earlier, with the decline entirely attributable to local government employment (in the educational services sub-sector).

Sectors adding jobs over the past 12 months included Education & Health Services (+3,400), Wholesale Trade (+1,700) and Construction (+1,400).

Metro-Area Employment
The annual march-madness of BLS data revisions was reflected in updated payroll data for metropolitan areas last week. The downward revision to the state total as of December (reported previously) was reflected in lower estimates of employment for Northwest Arkansas and Central Arkansas. Data for Jonesboro and Texarkana were revised upward.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

The data revisions had the effect of lowering two-year growth estimates for most metro areas, with the exceptions again being Jonesboro and Texarkana.

New data for February was also available following this morning’s state employment report. Declines were reported for four of the state’s metro areas, with gains reported for Hot Springs, Memphis and Texarkana. Jonesboro was unchanged. Compared to a year earlier, Fayetteville and Jonesboro top the list for job growth. Year-over-year declines were registered for Fort Smith, Little Rock and Pine Bluff. For Little Rock, the combination of data-revisions and the February decline make for a rather different trajectory for job growth than was indicated in the previously-published data.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

The figures below illustrate the effects of revisions and newly-released data on recent employment trends in Arkansas’ metro areas.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

# # #

Seasonally adjusted data for Arkansas nonfarm payroll employment, reported in a format consistent with the monthly news release from the Arkansas Department of Workforce Services, can be found here: Table-Seasonally Adjusted NFPE.

Arkansas Personal Income – 2019:Q4

The Bureau of Economic Analysis released new state-level personal income data for the final quarter of 2019. Total personal income in Arkansas is estimated to have increased at a 2.7% annual rate, slightly lower than the 3.0% rate for the nation. Arkansas third-quarter growth was also revised from the previously-reported 6.5% down to 3.1%. For the four quarters from 2018:Q4 through 2019:Q4, Arkansas personal income increased 3.4%. Over the same period the nationwide total increased 4.1%.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Focusing on the fourth quarter, personal income gains were entirely in the nonfarm sectors, with farm income down at a 2.3% annual rate. However, the decline in farm income was tiny compared to the increase at annualized rate of 21,771% that was reported in the third quarter (revised up to nearly 29,000% in yesterday’s report). Annualized quarterly percent changes are not necessarily a revealing way to view a series that has been as volatile as farm income. The third quarter increase reflected increased payments associated with the Department of Agriculture’s Market Facilitation Program. The fourth quarter figures suggest that those payments continued to be relevant. For the year as a whole, Arkansas farm income was down 34% from 2018.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Earnings were up at a 3.6% rate, for both Arkansas and the U.S, with growth in wages and salaries, supplements, and proprietors’ income supporting that growth. Growth in dividends, interest and rent slowed to 1.1% and transfer receipts increased a rate of 2.09% — both lower than the corresponding national rates.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Growth in earnings accounted for 2.2% of the 2.7% personal income growth rate. Breaking down the contributions by sector, the largest gains — for both Arkansas and the nation — came from health care sector. Prominent gains in construction and in transportation & warehousing were also relevant. In Arkansas, management of companies and enterprises was also a contributing factor to growth.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Annual Data
Annual averages show that Arkansas personal income was up 3.9% in 2019, down from the 4.5% growth rate in 2018.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Nationwide, annual growth averaged 4.4%. Growth rates by state ranged from 6.1% in Colorado to 2.8% in West Virginia. Arkansas’ 3.9% growth rate ranked 32nd among the 50 states.

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

Impact of Covid-19 on the Arkansas Economic Outlook

(Revised version – Corrected Table 2, March 30, 2020)

As the impact of the novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) works its way through the economy, national economic forecasts are showing an increasingly grim outlook. In addition to disruption of world supply chains, the decline in consumer spending associated with “social distancing” is generating forecasts with significant declines in aggregate demand that make a recession appear inevitable.

On Friday, March 20, IHS Markit released their latest forecast for the U.S. economy, projecting a second-quarter decline in GDP of 12.6% (annual rate), with a rebound not coming until the fourth quarter of the year. The IHS forecast suggests decline in payroll employment of 9.9 million (-5.6%) by the fourth quarter, with the unemployment rate peaking at 8.8%. Personal income and spending are expected to decline in the second and third quarters, with losses totaling 2.4% and 4.2%, respectively.

The IHS Markit Forecast for the U.S. assumed that “recovery from the looming economic contraction begins in August, by which time we expect the rate of new cases of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) to be dwindling and quarantines, official and self-imposed, to be lifting. It is not until the fourth quarter that a firm rebound takes hold.” Labor markets are expected to take somewhat longer to bounce back.

IHS forecasters have not yet released updated state-level forecasts, but by applying the new assumptions for the national model to the Arkansas model, we can estimate the magnitude of the Covid-19 impact on our state’s economy. To a large extent, the forecast for Arkansas reflects a direct application of changes in national aggregates to state-level variables. However, we’ve taken care to apply forecast adjustments on a disaggregated basis in order to account for unique characteristics of the Arkansas economy. For example, because a relatively large share of Arkansas workforce is engaged in goods-producing employment, some declines in service-sector employment have a smaller impact on total employment in Arkansas than at the national level.

In the following sections, we present post Covid-19 forecasts against a Baseline that represents projections from the IHS Markit model for Arkansas, published March 16, adjusted for benchmark revisions to employment that were subsequently announced by the BLS. The Covid-19 adjustment factors are calculated by comparing the IHS U.S. forecast from March 20 to the previously-published March baseline.

Employment
The impact of “social distancing” on employment is concentrated in service-providing sectors. For example, from the first quarter through the fourth quarter, employment in the Retail Trade sector is expected to decline 16%. Employment in Arts, Entertainment and Recreation is expected to fall 20%. In contrast, jobs in Health Care and Social Assistance are expected to increase by 2%. Overall, the decline in payroll employment is expected to total more than 77,000, a drop of 6.0% .

Figure 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Table 1:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Unemployment
The declines in payroll employment will be mirrored in the household measure of employment, with the number employed falling by more than 83 thousand by the fourth quarter, and with the number unemployed rising by nearly 70 thousand to total 117.5 thousand. With these developments, the unemployment rate is forecast to peak at 8.7%.

Figure 2:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Personal Income
Personal income is forecast to be reduced by job losses and business closings, but declines are expected to be mitigated somewhat by increases in transfer payments. From the first quarter of 2020 through the third quarter, personal income is projected to decline by 2.3% before starting to recover in the fourth quarter.

Figure 3:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Consumption
Social distancing practices are having a direct effect on consumer spending in the first and second quarters of 2020, with lingering effects due to the impact of declining employment and income later in the year and beyond. Total consumer spending is expected to decline by 5.1% in the second quarter of 2020. While spending begins to recover in the second half of the year, total consumer spending is expected to remain far below the baseline forecast through the end of 2021.

Figure 4:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Overall spending is also impacted by recent sharp declines in energy prices, with a 51% decline forecast for spending in that category. Note that spending on Food & Beverages for Off-Premises Consumption is expected to increase 13%, as households substitute food prepared at home for restaurant meals.

Table 2:

Sources: IHS Markit, Arkansas Economic Development Institute

Summary and Outlook
There is a great deal of uncertainty associated with any forecast of the current, unprecedented situation. Risks to the forecast are more likely to be on the down-side: The presumed scenario where economic recovery begins by the end of 2020 might prove to be overly optimistic. The declines in consumer spending and income may reinforce one another to create an even more dramatic downturn.

The outlook will undoubtedly change as the situation develops, particularly when it comes to the impact of fiscal and monetary policy responses. At the present time, however, it appears that a dramatic downturn in economic activity over the remainder of 2020 is unavoidable for the nation and for Arkansas.

A PDF file of this report is available HERE.

Arkansas Employment and Unemployment – January 2020

Arkansas’ unemployment rate was unchanged at 3.5% in January. The number of unemployed declined by 120, while the number employed increased by 2,155. Over the past 12 months, the number of unemployed has fallen by 720 while the number employed has risen by 4,697 (an increase of 0.4%).

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

Payroll Employment
Arkansas nonfarm payroll employment increased by 400 in January (seasonally adjusted). After the annual benchmark revisions to recent data, the January employment level was only 2,900 higher than in January 2019 (an annual growth rate of 0.3%).

Employment in most sectors expanded in January, but the notable exceptions of Manufacturing (-1,200) and Professional & Business Services (-2,400). The monthly press release from the Arkansas Division of Workforce Services reported that the decline in manufacturing was attributable to durable goods manufacturing, “with reported contractions in fabricated metal products and in transportation equipment manufacturing.” Including mark-downs to previously-reported growth in revised data, Manufacturing was down by 2,200 jobs compared to January 2019.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

Benchmark Revisions
Today’s data release included the annual “benchmark revisions” to the state payroll data. Not seasonally adjusted data beginning with April 2018 and seasonally adjusted data beginning with January 2015 were subject to revision. After revision, total nonfarm payroll employment in December 2019 was 5,900 jobs below the number that was originally reported.

As shown in the figure below, the revised employment data indicate quite a different growth pattern than the previously-reported data. The unrevised figures suggested fairly steady growth over the past two years, with a growth rate of 1.0% in 2018 and 1.4% in 2019 (December-to-December). The revised figures show higher growth for 2018 (1.5%), but considerably slower net growth in 2019. From December 2018 through December 2019, cumulative employment growth was only 0.5%. The revised data suggest that employment declined, on net, from January through September of 2019, then regained those losses only during the final quarter of the year.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

A breakdown of employment revisions by sector shows that some sectors are estimated to have grown more slowly than earlier reports indicated, while others have expanded more rapidly. For example, over the two-year period from December 2017 through December 2019, employment in Wholesale Trade was originally reported to be 7.3%. After revision, growth of only 4.9% remains. Sectors that are now estimated to have grown more rapidly than previously reported include Transportation and Utilities and Other Services.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

The figures below illustrate the impact of benchmark revisions on Arkansas employment by sector:

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)

# # #

Seasonally adjusted data for Arkansas nonfarm payroll employment, reported in a format consistent with the monthly news release from the Arkansas Department of Workforce Services, can be found here: Table-Seasonally Adjusted NFPE.

Arkansas Unemployment – 2019 (Revised)

It’s data-revision season at the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Today we saw the release of revised household employment and unemployment statistics by state. For Arkansas, the changes were fairly minor, with the revised figure for the state’s annual unemployment rate in 2019, 3.5%, unchanged from previously-reported estimates. As shown in the figure below, the revisions had the effect of smoothing some of the monthly ups-and-downs in the data over the past several months. The revised data show the unemployment rate at year-end to be 3.5%, one-tenth below the 3.6% originally reported.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

One aspect of the revision that is noteworthy: As previously reported, Arkansas’ unemployment rate declined to 3.4% in July and August last year, establishing a new record low for the series. The revised data do not show that slight summer dip, so the officially recorded low for the series is now 3.5%.

Revisions to the underlying components of the unemployment rate indicated modest changes. Originally, the number of unemployed was reported to have expanded to over 50,000 in early 2019, then dropping below 47,000 during the summer months. The revised data show the number of unemployed to be steady throughout the year, moving narrowly within a range of 48,000 to 49,000. Both employment and the labor force were revised higher for the latter part of 2018, lower during mid-2019, and ending the year slightly lower than originally reported.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

The impact of the revisions on household employment growth is shown in the figure below. Over the full two-year period from December 2017 through December 2019, the state’s employment growth rate was revised down from 0.8% to 0.7%. Growth rates over that time show a somewhat different pattern for pre-revision vs. post-revision data: It was previously reported that employment growth slowed during mid-2018 then ended 2019 with an acceleration. The revised data suggest stronger employment growth during 2018, but with the growth rate sagging to below 0.5% during the latter part of 2019.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

Metro Area Employment and Unemployment – December 2019

Unemployment rates in Arkansas metro areas were little changed in December. The rate declined by one-tenth of a percent in Memphis, to 4.1%, and increased by one-tenth in Pine Bluff, to 5.3%. Compared to a year earlier, the unemployment rate in Texarkana was down 0.9%, with smaller year-over-year declines reported for Jonesboro, Hot Springs and Northwest Arkansas. Memphis and Pine Bluff saw slight increases since December 2018, while Fort Smith and Little Rock saw zero net change over course of the year.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Smoothed Seasonally Adjusted Metropolitan Area Estimates

Annual averages for metro area unemployment rates will not be published until March 4th, after the annual data revision process is completed. Using preliminary data, the figure below shows un-revised, unofficial averages for the year. For the year, unemployment rates were lower than the statewide average in Fayetteville, Jonesboro and Little Rock, while rates were above-average in Memphis, Pine Bluff and Texarkana. Unemployment rates in Fort Smith and Hot Springs were approximately equal to the statewide average.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

Payroll Employment
Nonfarm payroll employment increased in five of the state’s metro areas in December, with the largest increase in Northwest Arkansas (0.5%). Memphis and Texarkana saw slight declines for the month, while Jonesboro and Pine Bluff experienced no net change.

Compared to a year earlier, employment was down by 1.8% in Pine Bluff, but was unchanged or higher in Arkansas’ other metro areas. Fayetteville and Jonesboro continued to show the fastest growth, with rates of 4.1% and 2.6%, respectively.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics (CES)